SOMERDALE -- When 11-year-old Matthew Dieterle played trumpet in the Somerdale
Park School holiday concert, his father held a cell phone in the air so
his mother, who was home, could hear him play.
When it was time for parent-teacher conferences, Laura Dieterle told
her husband, David, what to ask their children's teachers. And for
Matthew's first basketball game, David Dieterle had to cheer loud
enough for both parents.
"It wasn't the same when my mom wasn't
there rooting for me," Matthew said. "She always used to be there all
the time, and now she can't come on school property. So yeah, it's
tough."
In a move that some education law experts say may be the
first of its kind, the Somerdale school board unanimously voted in
September to ban Laura Dieterle, 37, from school grounds.
The
board cited "health and safety reasons" and the district's attorney
says that Dieterle has demonstrated "violent tendencies" after repeated
confrontations with school staff.
But Laura Dieterle, who is a
school crossing guard employed by the Somerdale Police Department,
believes she is nothing more than an active parent who angered the
district by asking about a lawsuit related to a sexual harassment
complaint against the superintendent.
Two weeks ago, Dieterle
sent a letter to the school board, which she hopes will be considered
at a meeting Wednesday, promising to stay away from board meetings for
the rest of the year if she's allowed to attend some activities.
"They're
only little once, and this is the time they need us the most," Dieterle
said, describing how she was even forbidden from dropping off
medication for her 6-year-old daughter, Brittany.
In barring
Dieterle, the district's attorney cites a ban, upheld last year by a
federal judge, that limited a Shawnee High School father's presence at
the Medford school after alleged threats to his son's wrestling coach.
In
that case, the father could still attend his son's matches as long as
he didn't speak to staff or students and notified school officials when
he arrived and left.
"The only times I've seen where there's real
outright bans on showing yourself at any school thing at all is when
the person is a registered sex offender," said Tom Hutton, staff
attorney for the School Boards Association in Washington, D.C.
Board
attorney John Kennedy said Dieterle has been repeatedly confrontational
with school staff and she failed to conduct herself in a "respectful or
professional manner."
"And there was concern that she was doing
this during school hours," said Kennedy, who represents the
470-student, one-school, K-8 district. "So there was concern with
regard to the safety of not only the staff but the students."
The
conflict between Dieterle and the school, documented in written
warnings and legal threats from the superintendent and board attorney,
reached a tipping point in November 2006, when the police were called.
Business
Administrator Kelly Peters accused Dieterle of pulling off a storm
drainpipe cover in front of the school. Dieterle said she saw the cover
was loose over an open hole and, concerned about children's safety, she
complained.
A confrontation followed, during which Dieterle called Peters a "wench," Peters told police.
No
charges were filed at the time. Superintendent Debra Bruner warned
Dieterle in a Nov. 6, 2006, letter that she could soon "lose all
visiting privileges to our school."
Undeterred, Dieterle
continued to attend board meetings to ask about a lawsuit against the
district, board and superintendent filed by a former buildings and
grounds supervisor, Joseph Fallon Jr.
Fallon claimed he was fired
in 2003 in retaliation for a sexual harassment grievance he filed
against Bruner claiming she repeatedly brushed her body against his and
pet his arm.
The wrongful termination suit was settled in April
and is sealed by the terms of the settlement, Kennedy said. Legal fees
were $41,118.99. But, before it was settled, Dieterle made more than 75
copies of the lawsuit to pass out to residents.
And then in
September, she did something she believes was the final straw that
prompted the ban: She wrote about the case in white marker on three
sides of her car, and then parked it at the building on the first day
of school.
"I needed support from more people to ask, 'Why are we paying for this lawsuit? How can I trust my kids are safe?' " she said.
That
same day, the district filed a criminal mischief charge against
Dieterle for the drain pipe incident 10 months earlier, and demanded
between $300 and $2,000 for repairs.
Dieterle pleaded guilty to a lesser nuisance charge, which she said she now regrets. The restitution matter is still in court.
By
late September, the school board voted 6-0 to ban Dieterle from school
property. Kennedy denies that Dieterle's constant questions about the
lawsuit had anything to do with her banishment or the drain pipe
charges. He said there was a "confrontation" but he declined to go into
specifics.
One ally, neighbor Tom DiPaolo Jr., who blogs about
Somerdale for courierpostonline.com, described Dieterle as a
"wonderful" person and mother.
"She's passionate about her kids,
she's passionate about what goes on at that school, but she's not a
danger to anyone," DiPaolo said.
This article appeared in the Courier-Post. Photo by John Ziomek of the Courier-Post.
|